Monday, November 1, 2010

The Concept of a "Border"

As John Washington employs in The New Colossus: Exploring the Idea of Border, a border can possess several different meanings. A border can be a simple line drawn on a map or it can be a terrifying experience for an individual to cross. A border stretches as far from the simple border around the University of Arizona to the borders that surround the United States. Although they are contrasting, each so-called border blocks out someone or something.
The author of this piece is extremely biased to the idea of an individual being "dumped" back to their home town. Johh Washington has experienced several first hand encounters with migrants who are tattered and worn. Those who have risked everything to come to America in hope to better their family.
It can be determined that the author chose to put himself in a position where he would be seeing to gruesome aspects of migration. Yet in choosing to volunteer at Nogales, Washington has seen how harshly migrants are treated and subsequently has this opportunity to share a taste of what he has witnessed. In choosing to share with others the extremities he has witnessed, hopefully action can be taken to lesser the treatment of migrants. Although there are reasons as to why they are treated in such a way, it is still inhumane. I wish that migrants would learn how brutal the experience will be and that less will partake.
Washington brings in several specific examples to prove his point. For example, he brings up "the line of control" which is the border between India and Pakistan and how it has sparked wars and violence since its existence. Washington is iterating that borders cause violence, although they are necessary Washington hopes to bring awareness to citizens of America of the extremities of borders. Washington has several accounts where he meets an individual who has gone through more than they can handle. He sees their pain and hears their cry. I know if I was in that position I would want to help them and bring them back to health. But it is not as easy done as it is said. If an individual is here illegally there is no other chose but to "dump" them based on our laws. Washington brings up the Halloween costumes sold in local stores last Halloween of an illegal alien. This proves how America feels that illegal aliens are not worthy to be here. Yes it is illegal and legal actions will be taken. But if a child sees that costume they will feel as though the matter is comical and that illegal aliens are somehow aliens and inhuman. Washington brings up several strong arguments as to support his claim that no human should merely be "dumped" as if they are garbage. Hopefully this essay will bring more awareness to American's the extreme measures that are taken towards migrants.

3 comments:

  1. I agree that Washington used many of these different rhetorical strategies to incorporate all of his different ideas about illegal immigration. It is interesting that you say that you wish that immigrants would see how brutal it is and less would partake. I think many if not all realize the brutality but they go through with it anyway because they have no choice. They will endure the risks in order to provide for their family. I too hope that there will be more awareness brought to American's extreme measures that are taken towards migrants. I enjoyed reading your imput!

    ReplyDelete
  2. That was a really good post. I agree with you Alison. Life is really hard and even with the way the laws are, it is still easier to come over the border. I wish that there was something more that could be done because inhumane treatment of another human being is wrong. I really like what you wrote, you brought up some good points to think about.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alison, your end comment really strikes me. In fact, it seems to relate to the film "Life is Beautiful" in the controversy over comedy and humor. When is it appropriate and when isn't it appropriate? This would be a very interesting topic for your Essay 3.

    ReplyDelete